I Auditioned for America’s Got Talent to Find Out If I’ve Got Talent
Illustration by Jim Cooke/GMG. Photo by Joanna Rothkopf.
A man has built himself a bubble bath out of balloons. He is
asking two teenage girls—who have volunteered for this, but
still—to stand in the bathtub and sing a song, which they do,
until it’s clear that everyone is miserable.
He hands one of them an inflated “washboard,” and says, “You’re
going to have to work today,” and immediately visibly regrets
his choice of words.
Eventually, a producer gives a signal that the girls are
allowed to get out of the tub and go back to their families.
And they do, quickly, and joylessly.
I’m behind the group, sitting next to a clown who has been
spinning a plate for so long that I’m not sure he remembers
he’s doing it. We’ve been waiting here for hours, like the poor
dove a magician keeps in his pocket for six hours, waiting for
the opportune time to pull it out to impress a child who will
most likely be more scared than they are amazed. And we all
chose to be here because we’re all auditioning to be on
You’ve undoubtedly watched one of this brand of talent
shows—The Voice, maybe, or So You Think You Can
Dance?—and thought, These people are god awful; I
could easily do better. Every American has. It’s why the
shows are successful—because we can feel the simultaneous
tugging of jealousy that we aren’t the ones who waited
in a year-long line in the rain after traveling 4,000 miles to
the closest audition city, with nothing but a liter bag full of
craisins and a dream, and the begrudging recognition that some
of these people actually are quite good.
Anyway, I’ve felt those things too, which is why I found myself
auditioning for the misfit cousin of the talent contests, the
one that allows anyone to do literally anything for any reason:
America’s Got Talent, which is currently under fire after a couple claimed that new
host Tyra Banks “humiliated” their daughter during filming. I
did this to see what it was like for journalism, but also, just
After being sued earlier this week for “infliction of
emotional distress and civil assault and…
When you register online to audition for the show, you have to
choose a talent from a drop down menu that lists your standard
selection of reality show talents, and, the dangerous “Other.”
To make my decision, I decide to poll my Jezebel colleagues:
Should I a) sing a song; b) do a dance; or c) perform broad,
hacky standup? They unanimously vote for standup, which, in
retrospect, is a blessed relief, since it is by far the easiest
thing for me to get together, and doesn’t involve any spandex.
Image via Screenshot/AGT.
I write a five minute “set,” heavily relying on the idea that
I’ll be performing in front of the show’s celebrity judges,
Howie Mandel, Mel B, Heidi Klum, and Simon Cowell (or at least
pretending to audition in front of them) and can do
some gentle, family-friendly sparring. Then, I largely forget
that I’ll one day actually have to perform it.
But if time does anything, it passes, and on Friday, January 27
I wake up dutifully at 6 a.m. and make my way to Queens College
in Flushing to humiliate myself in front of America’s most
talented and most judgmental. The day was interminably long and
boring, and in the recounting that follows, I’ve spared no
I am dropped off by a hideously expensive Lyft on the exact
wrong side of campus, even though I follow the
AGT-provided instructions precisely, and see no sign
of any anything show-related. I am forced to ask a security
guard the one thing you hope to never ask anyone—that is,
“Where are the America’s Got Talent auditions?”—and
after some brief but confusing instructions, I make my way
almost fifteen minutes across campus to try to find the gym
with the “green roof.” Along the way, two lost-looking teens
ask if I know the way to auditions. I say, “Yes, I am going
there too,” and they follow me. Still, I know only vaguely
where I am going—toward the green building—and inadvertently
lead them into an abandoned-feeling industrial alley, at which
point they look at each other (I see them do it) and at me and
asked, “Are you sure you know where you’re going?” All too
aware of my big adult body that has led minors into an alley, I
accidentally yell that yes I did!, that it’s just a
few buildings away, and I’m feeling freaked out too!
When we get to the gym (the girls rapidly abandon me and fly
inside) there aren’t any visible crowds lined up, as I had
expected from those iconic pan shots of thousands of cheering
prospective auditioners in coats and hats, and, like, one of
them is tap dancing on the pavement and everyone is laughing
and clapping along, and maybe another one is doing vocal warm
ups and another is trying to make a woman laugh with insult
comedy. But here, there were only a handful of AGT
employees in AGT shirts and a group of 13 teens with
their parents. Disappointing.
It’s unclear whether or not this remains the scene outside the
auditorium for the rest of the day, or if crowds suddenly
manifest themselves out of thin air for that shot. Because I
will spend the next six hours indoors, being shuttled from
holding pen to waiting area to bathroom stall and back.
To enter the auditorium, you need a wristband—pink if you’re an
auditioner; green if you’re “support.” I ask for one pink
wristband please, show my audition confirmation number, and
said no, ma’am, I don’t have any support. I am a 27-year-old
single woman, off to humiliate myself in front of an-as of-yet
unidentified panel of producers and possibly celebrities, and I
am all alone, making it seem all the more deadly serious.
Once inside the college gym, you get yourself wanded by some
kind of tricked-out security guard, and walk through a few
halls and up stairs until you reach the gym, and this
is where the shit gets real—when I arrive, there are already a
couple hundred auditioners already milling around. First, we
are told to wait in a mile-long (probably) roped-off line area
to officially register and get stickers with our numbers on it
(mine, for proof, ends up being 1209518). I wind my way back
and forth and back and forth through the line like a good
rule-follower, while other bitch moms and their bitch kids
stepped over the ropes, cutting me in line and probably
stealing my chance at fame, too. An Orthodox Jewish father and
daughter step boldly in front of me as I round a corner, which
is not very Godly. Another particularly bold mother with a
group of children holding instruments (a family band?) walk
straight to the front of the line and yell, “WE SIGNED UP FOR
AN AUDITION TIME.” But in the land of AGT, she learns,
audition times don’t matter. Everyone—no matter how
much they’ve got talent—is at the mercy of the line, and of the
50 or so producers and show volunteers guiding us around like
cows being led to the killing room.
In this first line I see: Approximately 100 young boys with
gelled-up hair, guitars, and just terrible attitudes, an
unsupervised seven-year-old, several child dance teams (one
with matching uniforms that had affixed to them names including
“Riley” and “Shaelyn” and “Katrina” in rhinestones), and a man
in a cowboy hat and leather jacket (a character, if you will).
Of the maybe 200 people I wait in line with, only a handful are
adults. Is this a show for children? I am the only person in a
sweater as far as my eyes can see. In their costumes, everyone
around me looks like they’ve been plucked directly from Matty
B’s YouTube channel, or the Michael Jackson Academy of
Professional Children, and I look like I’m going to a Christmas
party. Can I be arrested for wearing such a pervy outfit choice
around all these minors? Maybe, but then again, so can Howie
As I reach the front of this line, I stand beside a dad and his
devastatingly shy-looking teenage daughter, who holds a folder
(probably containing sheet music) with the words “Pereoid 4″
written on the front. I love her, and I wish her confidence and
for some kind of Susan Boyle moment. But before I can introduce
myself to her and maybe pat her on the head, I am called up by
a volunteer, show my ID and documents (I am praised for being
“so prepared”), am given a sticker with my number on it and
several forms to fill out. I take these forms to yet another
holding area in the same room, this one just five rows of
people sitting on the floor like animals, if you care.
I’m realizing at this point that I can’t name a single act made
famous, however fleetingly, by this show, except for the man
who jumps from a very high height into a baby swimming pool
(Professor Splash, I see now) and
Nick Cannon. If someone asked me what
AGT star I loved, like I was in an interview, I’d have
to say baby pool man. This is not an ideal situation if one
wants to be viewed as a real contender and not a spy. It’s also
not ideal if I want to be viewed as a journalist who properly
prepared for her assignment. But my heart is filled with
regrets much more pressing than, “I wish I had watched more
episodes of this stupid talent contest,” and so, I move on.
In a Facebook post on Monday, Nick Cannon announced he would
be leaving America’s Got Talent after…
In this new line, I am so overwhelmed by the number of faces
and bodies in the room that I begin to feel anxious and
nauseous, like I am floating in an uninterrupted sea of flesh,
while the flesh yells, “I am passionate about
SINGING-SONGWRITING!” To cope, I turn my attention to my forms.
The main one asks you general information about you and your
talent, clearly with the intention of guiding producers to
auditioners with a special kind of tear-jerky or inspiring
story. I fill my own form out in the following way:
WHAT IS YOUR DREAM: To make it through this
audition without crying or vomiting.
WHAT OBSTACLES HAVE YOU OVERCOME IN PURSUING YOUR
ACT: Crippling shyness, a generally weak body.
TALK ABOUT YOUR BIGGEST SUPPORTER: My mom is
a therapist and has given me free diagnoses for my whole
WHY IS THIS TALENT IMPORTANT TO YOU: We must
all laugh in the face of terror.
WHAT OTHER TALENTS DO YOU HAVE: Truly not
In front of me, I see a 12ish-year-old theater girl filling out
the form with her mother. She is too young to have developed
any sort of filter or shame, and is shouting her earnest
answers out for all to hear.
“My dream?!” she says as she writes, “My dream is to become a
SINGER. A SINGER or an AC-TA-RESS.”
“This talent is important because… Because I enjoy it.” She
thinks a minute and then writes instead, “Because I bring joy
This scene is soundtracked by another similarly-aged girl
belting highly obnoxious theater tunes. Another girl rips off
her outerwear to reveal a sparkly leotard. Somehow, I have
stumbled into the holding pen at Stagedoor Manor, I guess, or
the Westchester Summer Community Theater production of
We are ushered into a third holding area, where, for the first
time in two hours, we’ll actually be filmed for television.
This third holding area is what you think of when you think of
America’s Got Talent—blue carpets, bright lights
reading “America’s Got Talent!,” an eclectic collection of
children and several costumed adults practicing their routines
and shmoozing. The room is surrounded by cameras, and producers
are running around, setting up interesting shots and plucking
various people (a drag queen, a clown who I overhear is a
regular at these things, a little girl in a Russian dance
costume) to perform, or be prominently featured in shots.
I choose the first empty seat I see to sit down and start
eating a banana. From what I glean, auditioners are left here
to put final touches on their makeup and very publicly and
aggressively prepare for their auditions. If a producer asks
you to get up and perform for a camera, you get up and perform
for a camera.
I also learn that I have inadvertently chosen a seat in the
front row, in other words, directly in front of the one row of
cameras filming the room. This row, I’m observing, is reserved
for the most charismatic and remarkably-dressed of the
auditioners, and people who look like me (in all black,
actively frowning) are often asked to move to a seat deeper in
the crowd. Somehow, I’m not asked to move, but others around me
are, meaning I will almost certainly be on the show’s premiere
Tuesday evening if they use any sort of footage from the New
York City auditions. I am positioned between an adult clown, a
guy in bright red, and another man dressed in a suit of
sequins, and I hear a producer tell them to act like they’re
“You’re in sequins, and I’m in bright red and we’re still not
the craziest ones in the room,” one says, improvising capably.
Another man in a black-and-white skunk hat gets our attention,
“HOW YA DOIN’ LADIES AND GENTLEMEN?” I turn to him, hoping to
hear directions or some kind of update. It turns out he’s
auditioning too—he’s just trying to be a character. He’s
standing next to a man in a Union officer uniform holding a
10-foot-long flag pole and American flag. If I close my eyes, I
might hallucinate that I’m in the 1800s in a barren battle
field, but I can’t concentrate on this hallucination, or any,
because of the thick cloud of hairspray and historic thirst.
Later, a white belly dancer in full body paint is placed in a
group of children. She says to a boy in glasses, “You have
beautiful eyes.” He says, “Thank you.” A successful
Around me, auditioners and their supporters are having tricks
done to them by magicians and clowns and acrobats (including
the girls in the bubble bath), and are patiently acting
surprised and wowed, even when they might want to work on their
own material—because, as of now, we have no idea when we’ll be
called to audition, who it will be in front of, or whether or
not it will be taped (although it occurs to me that a portion
of people came to audition simply to be filmed in this holding
room watching other people, like it’s its own form of free,
I soon become one of the auditioners forced to witness, when a
teenage mentalist named Alex asks to film a trick with me for
his YouTube channel. I participate, and have since located the
One producer is polling the auditioners surrounding me about
what they think of the judges. I hope he asks me because I have
some great quips saved up that might be fun to air on
television. He doesn’t ask. I think it might be because I look
like a normal adult, but in my heart I suspect it’s because I
At this point I have done, redone, taken off, and done again my
makeup upwards of 10 times. I have eavesdropped on
conversations that range from awkward to boring, between break
dancers and stilt walkers, and 1,000 teenage singers. I have
eaten all my snacks and slurped all my water. When I feel I
cannot possibly go on, a range of numbers that includes mine is
called, and I get up, sick with nausea, and follow a
producer-led parade of auditioners down stairs, outside, and
into yet another building (!), where—you guessed it—we are
brought to another holding area.
This holding area is not on camera—our chance at fame was left
behind in the last building—and is in the college’s cafeteria.
It has a snack bar where you can buy hot food and chips and
several vending machines. Now, the clowns and magicians that
were once so animatedly performing for cameras in the other
room become human. They sit in the rows of plastic chairs here,
dejectedly looking at their phones or taking a nap like they’re
at the DMV. It is highly depressing and I am sapped of my
energy and mediocre attitude.
It is very clear how that one girl who is the best singer in
her grade, that one who is encouraged by her chorus teacher to
audition, stacks up against the competition here. In the past
four hours, I’ve seen at least 100 of them, and they all
basically look and sound the same. I weep for them in my heart,
and begin to fear I am one of them, even though I’m not a
singer, nor am I in high school (I am a large adult, which
isn’t better), but, in the end, I came here too. I have waited
far too long to be able to maintain any kind of ironic
detachment or sense of humor about the process.
I see the girl with the Orthodox Jewish father who cut me in
line and peek at her paperwork. I’m five numbers ahead of her,
and I feel a surge of spiteful joy.
After a bit of internal debate I purchase a red apple wrapped
in plastic and a French Vanilla coffee, a flavor I hate. They
are both inedible, and I throw them in the garbage.
I am now almost inconsolably depressed, and also angry. How
dare America’s Got Talent make Americans think they
got talent, when, in reality, only like 10 Americans got talent
and they are the Americans that win the show? And even those
Americans don’t go on to do anything particularly impressive,
since I can’t name a single one except for Nick Cannon?
One woman approaches a producer, claiming she has misplaced her
ID sticker which is stuck to the front of every other person.
How can she expect to got talent if she can’t even follow
simple instructions and hold onto her ID sticker? If your one
shot at fame involved holding onto a sticker that should be
stuck to you for five hours, don’t you think you’d be able to
This is the American dream,
and the American disappointment.
I am filled with despair. This is the American dream, and the
American disappointment: a bunch of people who are convinced
they got talent, so convinced that they drive (or take a
grotesquely expensive car) to Flushing, Queens at the tit crack
of dawn, only to wait for hours, ignored, in a miserable school
cafeteria. And what happens when they finally get called?
They’ll probably be rejected by the first set of screeners, and
never do their act for more than a producer’s assistant in a
closet. They’ll probably go find their mom, if they’re so lucky
and were able to bring their mom, in the waiting room and then
they’ll leave and go buy a tuna salad sandwich at a Duane Reade
and talk about what a good experience this all was.
But was it, though? What is there to gain from this
humiliation, except for crippling sadness, minor constipation,
and a better idea of just how small I am—I mean, we all are?
How can anyone even manage to got talent after this morning of
nearly-endless humiliations and degradation? And I have a job!
Why do I need this extra validation? Can’t I just stick to
writing “kind of funny” blog posts about tweets and die without
An elderly cross-eyed woman eats a sandwich while staring at
me, or just past me.
A producer calls my range of numbers. I am filled with supreme
dread—my face is dead white and cold as I float over to where
I’ve been called, following her and the rest of my group out of
this building, down a sidewalk, up some steps and into another
one. We are led into a hallway with a line of chairs placed
across the wall. We are to sit in these chairs until we are
called to go into a classroom in groups of ten (minors with
their parents), and do our act for another producer. When it is
done, we are to leave. We don’t know when we’ll find out if we
made it or not. Neither Heidi Klum nor Howie Mandel nor Mel B
are anywhere to be seen. I hear the children around me mutter
disappointedly, but I cannot console them, because I am an
adult, and I am also disappointed.
I say my act in my head several times, and then resolve to buck
the hell up. I have spent the morning on my own, but have
somehow reached my destination smack in between the girl with
the “Pereoid 4″ folder and her father, and the 12-year-old
aspiring SINGER OR AC-TA-RESS and her mother. If these young
girls, now my daughters and sisters in struggle, can do this,
then so can I.
We are called in. I am the last member of my group, meaning
“Pereoid 4,” who is behind me, will not be coming in with my
group. It also means, I learn in a
moment, that I am the finale of my audition section. Comprising
my group of 10—I kid you not—are nine children and their
parents, and me. I am the only adult who will perform for our
producer, a nice-looking man with a beard and a newsboy cap. I
think that he is the first person I’ve felt any sort of kinship
with all day, but that’s probably because he is closest to my
Of the nine teens in the group, most are singers, and some are
quite good. Two people sing “How Far I’ll Go,” from
Moana, and one girl nearly cries. One teen boy does an
impressive Stomp-esque percussion set with a cup and a
pencil, and even though he asks to start over because he messed
up, I assume that he also could be brought in for the next
round. The 12-year-old SINGER and AC-TA-RESS is,
unfortunately, not so good, but had a lot of spirit. I start to
loosen up—I am in a very weird situation and I am at least 10
years older than anyone else in the room (except for parents).
After everyone else has performed, the producer calls my name.
“You’re doing comedy? Let’s keep it clean, okay?” he advises. I
give him a very cool laugh, like we are on the same
team, and then I perform the following set with a charisma
produced exclusively from one bite of mealy apple and six hours
of crushing existential confusion. Here’s what I performed
(much of it lies), as I have it written down:
I am so excited to be auditioning for America’s
Got Talent. I just love these judges. Heidi Klum? The
most beautiful bird I’ve ever seen. Mel B? I’ve loved her my
But I’ve always wondered, what is a Scary Spice? If you’re
Donald Trump, every spice is scary, because he’s such a
Actually, it’s probably salt because of the heart
I’m seven-to-12 pounds overweight depending on whether… you
ask my mom or my dad. Just kidding, they haven’t looked at me
in a decade. Uch! I’m kidding again, we live together. Well,
I live in their basement. Okay, I’m squatting in their
basement—I’m squatting in a basement, can we please
stop talking about the abandoned basement I’m squatting in?
I live in New York City—single and hating it. So I’ve been
watching a lot of rom-coms. Do you ever notice how in
rom-coms, the girl and the guy are rivals before they get
together? Like, she’s the owner of an independent bookstore
on the Upper West Side, and he’s the head of the family… of
raccoons that live outside her bookstore.
Anyway, when I walk around New York, I’m always trying to
make an enemy because I know that guy will eventually be my
I black out most of the performance, although I notice a
smattering of friendly laughs from the parents in the room, and
a marked absence of any teen laughs. When I sit back down in my
desk chair after my set, a mom makes eye contact with me and
gives me a round of silent applause. I really need it, since,
if you don’t remember, I came here alone.
Moments later, the producer tells us something like, “We’ve had
a lot of amazingly talented people come out this year and
unfortunately we won’t be able to take any of you, but thanks
for coming out.” We are uniformly shocked, I think, that not a
single person makes it through—even the cup percussionist—but
there is nothing we can do, no complaints we can file or
envelopes to double check. So we pick up our bags and jet.
As I walk out of the classroom, I see Pereoid 4 and her dad,
waiting first in line to learn how quickly a morning of waiting
and months of preparation could be spoiled; the extent of their
wasted time. But before I can get very far, I hear, “Joanna—”
It is my bearded producer, whose name I never learned. “Hang
back a sec.”
Son of a pumpkin (keeping it family friendly), this is it. I
knew I wasn’t like any of these other untalented teens!!! First
of all, I was an adult. And second, I got talent! Joanna’s Got
Talent is the name of this show!!!
While I’m waiting for the teens and their parents to shuffle
out of the room, I make eye contact with Pereoid 4’s dad. He
gives me an encouraging nod and I give him one right back. We
are family, and with this one minuscule bit of reassurance, I
am suddenly immortal and better than. How easily I forget the
stripped-down reality of my own mortality that had become so
clear in the cafeteria.
He calls me back into the classroom and closes the door, and
for almost ten minutes, we are in there alone. An America’s
Got Talent producer and me, an American who’s got talent.
He says, “So, what else do you have?”
“You’re a standup right?”
“So, give me more material. I want to hear more.”
Haha, fuck, this is where it ends—by my own unpreparedness.
“I just prepared that little set—I assumed I’d go home and
write more if I got through,” I try.
“Come on, you must have something.”
He isn’t going to let me leave until I gave him more. I have no
more. We are at an impasse. What am I to do? I tell him I am a
full time writer and write funny essays, and can read him one
of those if he liked. “Funny essays? What?” he counters. “Just
It is at this point that I completely lose memory of what I say
or how I say it. What I do know is that I attempt to recite,
from memory, this essay about my woke
baby, that when read aloud I know to be supremely unfunny.
When recited from memory, poorly, it is even less funny. I also
know that while I tried, he maintained an expression of amused
patience. I really fucked this one up.
He tells me that I’m funny (oh please!), that I’m
playing a character (sure I am!), that I look like
Dakota Johnson and has anyone ever told me that before?
(only Jezebel commenters and Kelly Stout!). He also
tells me that he can’t send me through without more material
and that it “wasn’t really right for our main stage anyway.” A
rejection, but a personalized one!!! He also tells me that I
should “keep working on my material.”
I want to kiss his mouth and fly back to Manhattan with my own
wings. I leave the room knowing full well that I have been
intoxicated by the briefest glimmer of my own specialness; that
I am no better than the clown who goes to every talent show
audition just to be noticed one time. I will die, just like
Alex the Mentalist, and that white belly dancer, and one
thousand dance teams. But, for one second on January 27, I was
noticed, which is, in America, the best you can hope for.
This season of America’s Got Talent will premiere
tonight at 8 p.m. EST on NBC.